Someone gets deleted and you guys accept the story of the deleted player with no questions? Has timmie earned that kind of credibility?

I'm asking honestly, 'cause as far as I know he's just some guy in a two-bit tag who posts on AT every so often.

Edit: I'll add to that. martian is a guy I've known for close to 15 years now, and have met a few times in real life. I wouldn't say I know him really well given that most of my interactions with him have been online etc, but my impression of him has always that he's really fluffing smart and he's got his priorities straight: he knows his fun and he knows his work and he is good at both. Not only that, but other people whose commitment to the survival of this game I respect (yay admins!) picked martian to be the game mod, which suggests to me that I'm not the only person who thinks highly of martian.

So, who the hell is timmie and why the hell are people taking his word on this over martian's obvious action? Has timmie really earned that?