Well, what's more likely here?

A cheater who has been busted is lying about what has happened, or that an intelligent, diligent, serious, and competent moderator is doing a bad job?

I'm asking about timmie's credibility, because that is definitely at issue here, and based on my interactions with Titans he has absolutely none. All I've seen from Titans is that they're a mediocre group of players with a limited grasp on how the alliance game works, and a limited grasp on the concept of consequences.